慶應義塾大学学術情報リポジトリ(KOARA)KeiO Associated Repository of Academic resources

慶應義塾大学学術情報リポジトリ(KOARA)

Home  »»  Listing item  »»  Detail

Detail

Item Type Article
ID
AN00150430-00000137-0115  
Preview
Image
thumbnail  
Caption  
Full text
AN00150430-00000137-0115.pdf
Type :application/pdf Download
Size :427.0 KB
Last updated :Apr 8, 2016
Downloads : 649

Total downloads since Apr 8, 2016 : 649
 
Title
Title 絶対か相対か : 同一性と種別概念の結び付きをめぐって  
Kana ゼッタイ カ ソウタイ カ : ドウイツセイ ト シュベツ ガイネン ノ ムスビツキ オ メグッテ  
Romanization Zettai ka sotai ka : doitsusei to shubetsu gainen no musubitsuki o megutte  
Other Title
Title Absolute or relative? some controversies over the relationship between identity and sortal concepts  
Kana  
Romanization  
Creator
Name 横路, 佳幸  
Kana ヨコロ, ヨシユキ  
Romanization Yokoro, Yoshiyuki  
Affiliation 慶應義塾大学; 日本学術振興会  
Affiliation (Translated)  
Role  
Link  
Edition
publisher  
Place
東京  
Publisher
Name 三田哲學會  
Kana ミタ テツガクカイ  
Romanization Mita tetsugakukai  
Date
Issued (from:yyyy) 2016  
Issued (to:yyyy)  
Created (yyyy-mm-dd)  
Updated (yyyy-mm-dd)  
Captured (yyyy-mm-dd)  
Physical description
 
Source Title
Name 哲學  
Name (Translated)  
Volume  
Issue 137  
Year 2016  
Month 3  
Start page 115  
End page 143  
ISSN
05632099  
ISBN
 
DOI
URI
 
JaLCDOI
NII Article ID
 
Ichushi ID
 
Other ID
 
Doctoral dissertation
Dissertation Number  
Date of granted  
Degree name  
Degree grantor  
Abstract
What the relationship between identity and sortal concepts is like has been a problem for a long time. Peter Geach has championed what is called a relative identity thesis according to which identity must be relative to sortal concepts such as river and cat. Proponents of the particular kind of an absolute identity thesis, however, have taken some arguments against Geach's thesis, while they have agreed with the following basic idea : there are some strong ties between identity and sortal concepts. On the other hand, simple absolute identity theorists have even denied the idea and thus refused the sortalized elucidation of identity.
In this paper I shall organize drastically several conflicts between these three theses into some straightforward and mutually-connected arguments and describe exactly what principle or idea is disputed among them. Based on this insight, I conclude my paper by offering criticism toward these theses respectively and suggesting which position each thesis leads to in terms of modern metaphysics about identity.
 
Table of contents

 
Keyword
 
NDC
 
Note
投稿論文
 
Language
日本語  

英語  
Type of resource
text  
Genre
Journal Article  
Text version
 
Full text URI
 
Access conditions

 
Last modified date
Feb 22, 2017 14:54:00  
Creation date
Apr 08, 2016 13:33:52  
Registerd by
mediacenter
 
History
Feb 22, 2017    Modified; Title Kana, Title Roma-ji, Abstract.
Feb 22, 2017    Modified; Title Kana, Title Roma-ji.
 
Index
/ Public / 文学部 / [哲学] 哲学 / 137 (201603)
 
Related to