慶應義塾大学学術情報リポジトリ(KOARA)KeiO Associated Repository of Academic resources

慶應義塾大学学術情報リポジトリ(KOARA)

Home  »»  Listing item  »»  Detail

Detail

Item Type Article
ID
AN10030060-20000930-0137  
Preview
Image
thumbnail  
Caption  
Full text
AN10030060-20000930-0137.pdf
Type :application/pdf Download
Size :1014.0 KB
Last updated :Apr 27, 2007
Downloads : 2533

Total downloads since Apr 27, 2007 : 2533
 
Release Date
 
Title
Title エミリ・ディキンスンまたは回転するレトリック  
Kana エミリ ディキンスン マタワ カイテンスル レトリック  
Romanization Emiri Dikinsun matawa kaitensuru retorikku  
Other Title
Title In Emily's case : the rhetoric of circumference  
Kana  
Romanization  
Creator
Name 巽, 孝之  
Kana タツミ, タカユキ  
Romanization Tatsumi, Takayuki  
Affiliation  
Affiliation (Translated)  
Role  
Link  
Edition
 
Place
横浜  
Publisher
Name 慶應義塾大学日吉紀要刊行委員会  
Kana ケイオウ ギジュク ダイガク ヒヨシ キヨウ カンコウ イインカイ  
Romanization Keio gijuku daigaku hiyoshi kiyo kanko iinkai  
Date
Issued (from:yyyy) 2001  
Issued (to:yyyy)  
Created (yyyy-mm-dd)  
Updated (yyyy-mm-dd)  
Captured (yyyy-mm-dd)  
Physical description
 
Source Title
Name 慶應義塾大学日吉紀要. 英語英米文学  
Name (Translated)  
Volume  
Issue 37  
Year 2001  
Month 3  
Start page 137  
End page 160  
ISSN
 
ISBN
 
DOI
URI
JaLCDOI
NII Article ID
 
Ichushi ID
 
Other ID
103708  
Doctoral dissertation
Dissertation Number  
Date of granted  
Degree name  
Degree grantor  
Abstract
As Jack L. Capps mentions, although Emily Dickinson says of her poetry, "This is my letter to the World/That never wrote to Me," she also declares that "There is no Frigate like a Book/To take us lands away" (vii). Considering the Book as what the World wrote to her, one is certainly inclined to speak of the first citation as "an overstatement" (Capps 1). And yet, this logic takes us to a couple of necessary proposi-tions : first, the World that never wrote to her makes her "letter" quite marginal, "circumferential" in the Dickinsonian sense, to the World, and, second, it is not the World but the Book that wrote its "letter" to her. Indeed Dickinson might have kept reading books, all the more because the World never wrote back to her, but, simultaneously and paradoxically, it might have been her reading that made her writing marginal. We are unable to decide whether her alienated life in the world led her into the life within the Book or whether her (mis ) reading of books led her into her (mis) writing in the World (Paul de Man 69). This paper is concerned with clarifying how the cause and effect relationship between writing and reading becomes indeterminate in the poet. Here the place to start may be with a reconsideration of herkey-concept of "circumference". Did she write (about) circumference or read (something into) it ?  In one of her famous "letters" Dickinson writes: "...My business is Circumference" (To T. W. Higginson, July 1862, Selected Letters 176). And her original intention of circumference has often been located in Poem 883:    The Poets light but Lamps-   Themselves-go out    The Wicks they stimulate   If vital light    Inhere as do the Suns    Each Age a Lens    Disseminating their    Circumference -A conventional way of interpreting this poem has long been based upon theological perspective. Charles Anderson states: "The literal meaning of `Circumference' as the boundary of a circle (like the disks of the lamps) has been expanded by her special meaning into a sphere like the sun, radiating its light outward to infinity. If poets can light such lamps they are content to `go out' themselves, for death then becomes a means of going outward to illuminate the darkness surrounding the genera-tions of man. The mortal life has been transfigured into the enduring life of their poems" (Emily Dickinson's Poetry: Stairway of Surprise 58-59). The poets are, however, not necessarily religious. Anderson's mistake lies in his regarding this poem as representative of her visionof infinity. This poem rather reflects Dickinson's poetics, revealing its self-reflexive and metapoetical characteristics. Accordingly, it might be more aptly suggested that as the poets go out and their poems' margin invites the dissemination of meaning, so it is not the wicks of the lamp but their circumference that enjoys its dissemination.  Another metapoem of hers makes this point clearer:This was a poet -it is That Distills amazing sense From ordinary Meanings-And Attar so immenseFrom the familiar species That perished by the Door-We wonder it was not ourselves Arrested it-before-(P 448)What attracts us here in the first place is the metaphorical equation of "sense" with "Attar" and of "Meanings" with "species". In terms of distilling "Attar so immense/From the familiar species" Dickinson allegorizes the act of writing as well as the act of reading ; although poetry always smells sweet, distilling its amazing and immense sense is, just like reading (amazing and immense sense into) /writing (amazing and immense) poetry, not so easy as it looks at first glance. To find the extraordinary (= "amazing") in the ordinary ("sense") is precisely to hover around the circumference of the ordinary, prolonging the dura-tion of the "extra-ordinary".  This hovering of the poet is skillfully expressed in another poemabout poems:Shall I take thee, the Poet said To the propounded word? Be stationed with the Candidates Till I have finer tried-The Poet searched Philology And when about to ring For the suspended Candidate There came unsummoned in-That portion of the Vision The Word applied to fill Not unto nomination The Cherubim reveal(P 1126)While the Poet writes a poem, he reads Philology, suspending "the propounded word" as the "Candidate". Then, he succeeds in reading "That portion of the Vision" into "The Word". This formula cannot but remind us of her reading something into "circumference"; if the Poet primarily writes a poem out of Philology which consists of numerous candidates, he is invariably confronted with circumferential words, not central. Exactly as words precede intentions, so circumference precedes center. In this respect the Dickinsonian writing and reading converge, as will be examined later. Put simply, her rhetoric springs from the obsession of "decentering".
 
Table of contents

 
Keyword
 
NDC
 
Note

 
Language
英語  
Type of resource
text  
Genre
Departmental Bulletin Paper  
Text version
publisher  
Related DOI
Access conditions

 
Last modified date
Apr 30, 2024 00:54:21  
Creation date
Apr 27, 2007 12:53:25  
Registerd by
mediacenter
 
History
 
Index
/ Public / The Hiyoshi Review / The Keio University Hiyoshi review of English studies / 37 (2000)
 
Related to