慶應義塾大学学術情報リポジトリ(KOARA)KeiO Associated Repository of Academic resources

慶應義塾大学学術情報リポジトリ(KOARA)

Home  »»  Listing item  »»  Detail

Detail

Item Type Article
ID
AN00003152-00000048-0025  
Preview
Image
thumbnail  
Caption  
Full text
AN00003152-00000048-0025.pdf
Type :application/pdf Download
Size :1.1 MB
Last updated :Nov 13, 2008
Downloads : 1907

Total downloads since Nov 13, 2008 : 1907
 
Release Date
 
Title
Title Brandon/Hill Listの収録基準の分析 : 医学図書館における学術雑誌選定のための評価基準を求めて  
Kana Brandon/Hill List ノ シュウロク キジュン ノ ブンセキ : イガク トショカン 二 オケル ガクジュツ ザッシ センテイ ノ タメ ノ ヒョウカ キジュン オ モトメテ  
Romanization Brandon/Hill List no shuroku kijun no bunseki : igaku toshokan ni okeru gakujutsu zasshi sentei no tame no hyoka kijun o motomete  
Other Title
Title An analysis of the selection criteria of the Brandon/Hill List : for the establishment of evaluation criteria for medical journals in medical libraries  
Kana  
Romanization  
Creator
Name 野坂, 美恵子  
Kana ノサカ, ミエコ  
Romanization Nosaka, Mieko  
Affiliation 東京医科大学図書館  
Affiliation (Translated) Tokyo Medical University Library  
Role  
Link  
Edition
 
Place
 
Publisher
Name 三田図書館・情報学会  
Kana ミタ トショカン ジョウホウ ガッカイ  
Romanization Mita toshokan joho gakkai  
Date
Issued (from:yyyy) 2002  
Issued (to:yyyy)  
Created (yyyy-mm-dd)  
Updated (yyyy-mm-dd)  
Captured (yyyy-mm-dd)  
Physical description
 
Source Title
Name Library and information science  
Name (Translated)  
Volume  
Issue 48  
Year 2002  
Month  
Start page 25  
End page 41  
ISSN
03734447  
ISBN
 
DOI
URI
JaLCDOI
NII Article ID
 
Ichushi ID
 
Other ID
 
Doctoral dissertation
Dissertation Number  
Date of granted  
Degree name  
Degree grantor  
Abstract
This paper examines whether journals covered by the Brandon/Hill List (B/H List journals)could be sorted out by specific evaluation items based on data that can be obtained publicly.Suppose B/H List journals were positioned in the higher rank by specific evaluation items orcombinations of items, then B/H List journals could be predicted to some extent using theevaluation items. That is, it would enable us to guess the selection criteria of the B/H List basedon those evaluation items. Although it would not be possible to know the real criteria,reasonable equivalents to the selection criteria of the B/H List could be attained using thoseevaluation items.   Impact factor, cited number, citing number, number of articles, cited number/citingnumber rate, first-publication year, price, price per issue, number of libraries archiving thejournal were used as the evaluation items. Data concerning these items were gained frompublic information resources. Cardiovascular system, internal medicine, and surgery weredetermined as sample fields from 46 fields of the B/H List 2001 edition. Journals from each fieldwere selected from the journal list of the 2000 edition of Journal Citation Reports on CD-ROMScience edition (JCR). There were 63 cardiovascular journals (7 were B/H list journals), 94 wereinternal medicine (14 were B/H list journals), and 132 were surgery journals (7 were B/H listjournals).   In the evaluation items scamined in this study, it became clear that “number of librariesarchiving the journal” and “impact factor” can sort out the B/H List journals to some extent.However, B/H List journals were not completely sorted out by the evaluation items used in thisresearch. This result suggests the need for seasoning with the additional factors such asexperience, the intuition and other personal knowledge of the librarian, which cannot beexpressed as an objective numerical value, to create journal selection criteria.
 
Table of contents

 
Keyword
 
NDC
 
Note

 
Language
日本語  
Type of resource
text  
Genre
Journal Article  
Text version
publisher  
Related DOI
Access conditions

 
Last modified date
Nov 12, 2008 17:10:18  
Creation date
Apr 20, 2007 10:19:47  
Registerd by
mediacenter
 
History
Nov 12, 2008    フリーキーワード, 本文 を変更
 
Index
/ Public / Faculty of Letters / Library and information science / 48 (2002)
 
Related to